Water Heater Pro technician speaking to a happy customer

How To Determine Whether To Repair Or Replace a Water Heater

Repairing or replacing a water heater is an important decision many homeowners must make regarding water heater issues. However, the question doesn’t always have to be confusing. 

Remember the factors below to quickly determine the type of change best for any water heater. 

THE AGE

The water heater’s age is a crucial factor to consider when it comes to replacement and repair. Most gas heaters can last up to 10 years, while tankless options can last twice as long. 

Water heaters that end their lifespan start to malfunction more often. That’s why homeowners with old water heaters that require repairs now and then should consider purchasing a new element. Doing so lowers the repair costs and makes the water heating system more efficient. 

INCREASING WATER BILLS

If a homeowner needs to turn their shower dial further every time to get the exact water temperature, it means their water heater isn’t as efficient. The fixture uses more energy to produce the same results, which in turn increases the energy bills. 

Since water heating plays an essential role in the overall energy bill, it’s not something to be ignored. However, replacing the whole fixture is often more cost-efficient if a water heater cannot produce hot water at the same level as before. 

FREQUENCY AND COST OF REPAIRS

Sometimes, the best way to discover if a water heater could benefit more from a repair or a replacement is to do a cost-benefit analysis. An easy trick to do this is the 50% rule. If a repair costs more than 50% of the replacement cost, it’s best to replace the heater rather than repair it. 

If the repair is less than 50% of the cost of a new heater, consider the frequency of the repairs. Chances are, the repairs happen more frequently as the water heater ages.

WHEN REPLACEMENT IS THE ONLY OPTION 

Sometimes, the repair costs may be low, and a water heater may be new; it could require replacement. However, the specific symptoms that indicate that heater replacement is the only possible choice are leaking, corroded, and broken water heaters.

Modern devices are much better insulated and made from heavy-duty materials that prevent corrosion early on. Still, if the three above mentioned symptoms appear, there’s little use in repairing the element. 

SOLVING THE REPAIR VS. REPLACE PUZZLE 

Water heaters are only as efficient as the quality of their construction, maintenance levels, and age allows it. When determining whether the item should be replaced or repaired, weigh the age, efficiency, water heating bills, and frequency of repairs to make the final decision. 

If the tips above are not helpful, contact professional plumbers from the area so they can make the final assessment.

Water Heater Pros provides water heater installation and replacement services for Las Vegas and surrounding area residents and businesses. Our expert technicians install both traditional and tankless water heaters for homes and other buildings with gas or electric service. We offer the highest quality installers for efficient, versatile water heaters such as Rheem. Ruud, high-efficiency tankless Navien units, and more. Ask about our installation specials.